Teenager Elliston Berry is calling on lawmakers to require that tech companies remove AI-generated pornography within two days of a report
    • @[email protected]
      -8•4 months ago

      So if I draw a stick figure with 2 circles, call it 8 years old, is it CSAM? Will I be arrested for it? Do you see how that dumb logic does not work too well?

        • @[email protected]
          -3•4 months ago

          Glad that it will always remain a hot take.

          The problem with your argument is there cannot be developed a scale or spectrum to judge where the fake stops and real starts for drawings or AI generated media. And since they were not recorded with a camera in real world, they cannot be real, no matter what your emotional response to such a deplorable defamation act may be. It is libel of an extreme order.

          Cuties was shot with a camera in real world. Do you see the difference between AI generated media and what Cuties was?

            • @[email protected]
              -4•4 months ago

              An image is not merely an arrangement of pixels in a jpeg,

              I am not one of those “it’s just pixels on a screen” people. But if it was not recorded in real world with a camera, it cannot be real.

              Who will be the judge? If there is some automated AI created, who will be the one creating it? Will it be perfect? No. We will end up in the situation that Google caused to users, like doctors, married parents and legitimate people being labelled as pedophiles or CSAM users. It has already happened to me in this thread, and you also said it. The only accurate way to judge it will be a very large team of forensic experts on image/video media, which is not feasible for the amount of data social media generates.

              not every law needs to have a perfectly defined line

              And this is where the abuse by elites, politicians and establishment starts. Activists and dissidents can be easily jailed by CSAM being planted, which would in this case be as simple as AI pictures being temporary drive by downloads onto target’s devices.

                • @[email protected]
                  -3•4 months ago

                  Have you considered the problem of doctors, married parents and other legitimate people being labelled as CSAM users and pedophiles? This has already happened, and they are not obligated to take the brunt of misjudgement of tools developed to judge such media. This is not a hypothetical scenario, and has already happened in real world, and has caused real world damage to people.

                  The argument of planted CSAM is not incoherent, but has also played out with many people. It is one of the favourite tools for elites and ruling politicians to use. I am less worried about it because such a law thankfully does not exist, that will misjudge the masses brutally for fictional media.